I thought long and hard for the past few days about whether or not I wanted to write this blog. At first, I thought I had to: that this movie made such a mockery of the intelligence of the general public—it’s a testament to what people
won’t question—that something has to be said. However, another part of me felt that come Monday morning, there would be droves of
blogs (hopefully) saying everything I was thinking, and that made me change my mind and decide I wanted to write the End All Be All on the subject... But I held off because there was no way in hell I would continue a debate about a movie that is not worth the effort. After reading so many of
these blogs t
his morning, though (and thankfully agreeing with most of them, proving that the general public is not just full of CGI-loving drones who
don’t question what makes
absolutely no f**king sense!), I’ve happily discovered that it is quite the opposite, actually; with the increasingly available information about filmmaking, audiences are becoming much more savvy and with the accessibility and anonymity of the internet, they are able to engage in quite witty, snarky dialogues. How could I not want to be a part of that???

All that being said, I’d be remiss if I didn’t throw my two cents in… so here it goes… The first thing that struck me about
Cloverfield was that it was supposed to be a love story set amid an inexplicable tragedy. That is set up from the opening frames of the “footage,” which feature a young man (is it a bad sign that some of the character names just didn’t stick in my mind?) and his girlfriend? one night stand? friend with benefits? waking up at the break of dawn in a ridiculously spacious New York apartment that overlooks Central Park. When the camera gets turned back on a month later, as the timestamp tells us, another man and woman are in possession of it (though at first glance, I admit I thought the new woman was the same woman, and I immediately went: “Uh oh, trouble in paradise.” Turns out I was right, but for other reasons) and planning a surprise going away party for the first guy. So that’s how we get introduced to all of the characters. Fine. A bit boring, but ultimately fine. That’s also when the chaos begins.
I can’t talk about
Cloverfield and not bring up the unnecessarily spot-on parallel to the collapse of the World Trade Center. As the party filters down and out of the apartment building, we are given images of thudding feet down stairs, a giant cloud of smoke tumbling down the street, and scared pedestrians running from their lives, getting covered in that white ash. It’s a moment that is still so real from six years ago, that I dry-swallowed for a moment, hoping it would be fleeting. And it was. And PS: there was no reason for that first building to crumble the way it did but for the September 11th parallel, and that is a low blow to tug at our emotions. So then I just got mad.

Now, originally I liked the overall concept of seeing a monster movie from the perspective of those involved; they don’t know what’s going on, and neither do we: we’re merely experiencing everything with them. Unfortunately, the camera work is so extremely distracting, it almost defeats the purpose of a monster movie: seeing the cool CGI effects or giant robot or puppet or whatever the particular movie used for the creature. Here we have shaking from side to side so quick that the image is a complete blur, and we have to strain to see even the littlest of details at times. We also have the “I’m standing with my elbow resting on my hip because my arm is just too darn tired to hold up this camcorder anymore” tilting of the camera, which creates stylized, slanted images for no good reason.
I also understand there is a certain amount of leniency you have to lend to a monster movie, which by nature is a surreal concept, but there were just too many little things that all only added up to the laziness of the filmmakers, who assumed no one would ask questions, or if they did, at least they’d do so
after shilling out their ten bucks to see the film. Little things like that aforementioned timestamp disappearing so that they don’t have to explain the ridiculous timetable of the film, even though we know the camera is not on the whole time (as evidenced by the gaps in tunnel walking or stair climbing, and we’ll get to that in a minute… and which explains how neither the battery nor the tape managed to run out). Little things like the fact that this guy doesn’t even blink when his brother gets blown up before his eyes, but when he hears a scared message from that possible girlfriend, starts in a panic to find her…

and his friends, including
Lizzy Caplan who seems to barely know them, all decide to follow him, despite the fact that there is literally a herd of people being evacuated behind them (I mention this because I know from firsthand experience that ‘follow the herd’ mentality during times of tragedy and panic, but following this
Michael Vartan-wannabe was not their only option). Little things like how the Mama Monster looked like a T-Rex, but how all the little babies that jumped off her looked like crab-spiders; I know they're parasites and not literally babies, but it's still a weird jump in species. Little things like the fact that they manage to get cell phone reception… no actually I’ll leave that one alone because looking back, I had cell phone reception on September 11th, so maybe those satellites really are just surprisingly advanced nowadays. Little things, though, like the Army just letting them go back out even after one of their friends has just combusted in front of their eyes; no one even stresses the importance of checking them for bites or deep scratches. Little things like seeing Possible Girlfriend’s apartment building has turned into the Leaning Tower of Pisa, and they get the brilliant idea to climb 59 stories up the
other building, jumping across the roof, and climbing down a slanted (there it is!) building to find a girl who, by all accounts,

should be dead. Little things like that girl is
not dead when they find her, and though she should at least be in shock and/or bleeding to death, she is perfectly able to scale the roof, fly down the 59 flights, and run out onto the street on her own two legs (yes, I know this is a common theme for Abrams, but the “Adrenaline!” excuse is just plain lazy!). Little things like turning these “average people” into Bionics when they survive a helicopter crash. Little things like how this footage and camera even managed to survive everything, and that in the end, someone was able (and cared enough) to sift through the thousands of pounds of rubble to find it.
In the last few moments of
Cloverfield, when the filming dude finally drops the damn camera, and it lays sad and abandoned on its side in the grass, I started to smile a little. I saw the end in my mind, and it slightly redeemed some of the other crazy sh*t that had taken place. I thought for sure the camera would stay there, and from the only wide shot we were allowed, we would see these three survivors die in a blaze of fire as the military leveled New York, as they promised they would when that Army man let these crazies back out onto the street. Sadly, though, that was not the case, as one more “shock value twist”

was thrust upon the audience, and then we were forcibly reminded that, at its core,
Cloverfield is not about destruction but love, and we have to hear Crazy Man and his Possible Girlfriend say they love each other as the city implodes around them. Well, I’d probably tell whomever I was with in the last moments of the world as I know it that I love them, too, but it doesn’t make it
real. It annoys me that movies never point this out. A similar issue occurred in the ABC Family Channel Original Film
Lovewrecked, which I watched a few weekends ago. Chris Carmack’s character only falls for Amanda Bynes’ character because he thinks he’s stranded and very possibly might die. Then when she, too, gets placed in life-threatening situation, suddenly her eyes open to the best friend who’s always been there for her, and she decides
she loves
him. It’s just the
adrenaline of the situation, if you will, and in the end it would never last.
Okay, sorry for the tangent. Rant Over. Thanks for indulging me.